In Southern PA, your roof is the only thing standing between your family and 90% humidity or 10 inches of snow. We’ve rounded up the top 10 local legends who actually know their way around a Lancaster limestone home or a York suburban split-level.
We’re Elmer’s Roofing. While we obviously think our Amish-built standards and “No-Mess” process make us the best choice, we want you to feel good about your decision. Here is the local leaderboard, starting with us at #1.
1. Elmer’s Roofing (Lancaster, PA)
We don’t just “fix roofs”, we treat your home like an investment, backed by 25+ years of a strong reputation and deep-rooted Amish values. Here is why we consistently take the top spot for Southern PA homeowners:
- The Famous “No-Mess” Guarantee: We use a hydraulic “roofing buggy” that catches debris at the roofline so your flower beds and landscaping stay perfect.
- 7-Year No-Leak Warranty: Most contractors offer a year or two of labor coverage; we give you a full 7-year workmanship guarantee because we trust our crew’s hands.
- GAF Lifetime Home Roofing System: We use the full GAF system, including leak barriers and Cobra attic ventilation, with shingles made locally in Myerstown, PA.
- Amish Craftsmanship: Our owner-operated teams are known for a disciplined work ethic, often finishing a total roof replacement in just one day.
- Absolute Cleanliness: We walk your yard with magnetic sweepers and promise that if you find a single nail, we’ll be back within 24 hours to make it right.
- Southern PA Roots: We’ve spent decades serving Lancaster, York, Chester, Berks, Delaware, and even Harford County, MD.
2. Middle Creek Roofing (Newmanstown, PA)
A massive regional player that is the go-to for high-volume residential work.
They have a huge team that can handle large-scale roof replacements on a tight schedule.
They are one of the few regional experts in specialized cedar shake installations.
Their team provides comprehensive storm damage inspections and insurance claim assistance.
They offer a range of premium materials including slate and metal roofing options.
3. Joyland Roofing (Ronks, PA)
A tech-forward company in Southern PA that focuses on transparency.
They provide video estimates so you can see exactly what the inspector sees on your roof.
Every crew is manufacturer-certified to ensure your material warranty is protected.
They use specialized roof-climbing equipment to ensure a thorough and safe inspection process.
Their customer portal allows for easy tracking of project timelines and documentation.
4. Zimmerman’s Roofing (New Holland, PA)
A family-owned shop with a massive focus on customer service.
They are excellent at diagnostic work and fixing leaks that other companies have missed.
They offer full exterior packages including high-end gutter systems and trim.
Their "Golden Rule" philosophy ensures a respectful and communicative experience for every homeowner.
They provide detailed, multi-point inspections to identify hidden structural issues before they become major repairs.
5. Greenawalt Roofing (Lancaster, PA)
A full-service contractor that handles everything from residential shingles to massive commercial projects.
A great choice if you need to coordinate roofing, siding, and windows at the same time.
They have a very professional office staff that handles communication and scheduling efficiently.
Their 24/7 emergency repair service provides peace of mind during severe Southern PA storms.
They offer flexible financing options to fit various homeowner budgets and project scales.
6. Klausmair Construction (Lancaster, PA)
Known for a straightforward, no-nonsense approach to residential roofing.
They’ve built a solid reputation in the Lancaster area for being honest and easy to work with.
A smaller feel where you get personal attention from the management.
They focus on durable, long-lasting asphalt shingle installations for local family homes.
Their pricing is consistently cited by customers as being fair and transparent.
7. Par One Construction (McSherrystown, PA)
A strong contender for homeowners on the Adams and York County side of Southern PA.
They are pros at helping homeowners navigate insurance claims after major storm damage.
They also handle larger home remodels, making them a versatile pick for exterior work.
Their team provides customized design consultations to help match new roofs with existing home aesthetics.
They have a strong track record of completing projects on time and within the quoted budget.
8. Abel & Son (Marietta, PA)
A name Southern PA has trusted for generations, especially for roof and siding combos.
They rely on a long history of word-of-mouth referrals and repeat business.
Known for quick, reliable service that has stood the test of time since the 90s.
They specialize in high-quality vinyl siding that pairs perfectly with their roofing systems.
Their family-run approach ensures a high level of accountability on every job site.
9. Red Well Roofing (New Holland, PA)
Brings traditional standards to both residential shingles and agricultural metal roofing.
They have a reputation for fair, transparent quotes without high-pressure sales.
A great choice if you have a barn or outbuilding that needs a durable metal roof.
They emphasize the use of high-gauge steel for superior impact and weather resistance.
Their crew is highly skilled in complex roof geometries common in older Pennsylvania farmhouses.
10. Bitner Brothers (Harrisburg/York Area)
Serving the northern edge of the region with a focus on long-term repair quality.
They have century-old roots in the area and a deep understanding of local building codes.
They are a solid choice for smaller repairs and maintenance that larger companies might pass on.
Their heritage in the trade means they have experience with older historical roofing materials.
They provide preventative maintenance plans to help extend the life of an existing Southern PA roof.
